What is the “mother-daughter” relationship? I have no direct information on this because I am non a girl. I do. nevertheless. have two sisters. and their relationship with my female parent is really different when compared to the characters in the short narratives “Who’s Irish? ” and “New York Day Women. ” Relationships between female parents and girls take different signifiers for different people. The mother/daughter relationship amongst different people can be the same. but besides really different.
There are many similarities in the relationships between the female parents and girls in the short narratives. “Who’s Irish? ” and “New York Day Women. ” One similarity is that there is a foundation of love between the coevalss. For illustration. in “Who’s Irish? ” the female parent seems to explicate how she feels about her when she was a babe. “A girl I have. a beautiful girl. I took attention of her when she could non keep her caput up. ” The storyteller seems to hold much love for her girl. and she tries to do her life better by taking attention of her kid. In “New York Day Women” the girl. Suzette. follows her female parent around New York City on her tiffin interruption and remarks on what she is making. In this short narrative it isn’t difficult to see that this girl loves her female parent really much. Suzette besides appears to cognize what her female parent does in her mundane life. and with this information she embraces her female parent with kindness and love.
For case. she knows that her female parent shouldn’t eat anything with Na because. “she has to be careful with her bosom. this twenty-four hours adult female. ” Another similarity would be that the civilizations of both female parents are held strongly with them. but non as strongly with their girls. For illustration. in “Who’s Irish? ” the female parent says. “You spank her. she’ll stop…” which in Chinese civilization it is acceptable to paddle your kid. However. Natalie answers. “…Oh no. In America. parents non supposed to paddle the kid. It gives them low ego esteem…” Which contradicts the Chinese parenting tradition performed to learn obeisance to the kid. In “New York Day Women” the female parent portrays herself as a individual who keep traditions strong but non hold them interfere with other civilizations such as the American civilization.
Although the female parent remains trussed to her civilization throughout the whole narrative. yet her girl is willing to accept her ways. but non follow them. An extra similarity in the two short narratives is the mothers’ attempts in seeking to encompass new civilizations. It is difficult for people of different backgrounds to understand the alteration in civilization in a state where the civilization is wholly different and diverse. However. the willingness of the two female parents to accept the civilization is their manner of showing their love for their kids. For illustration. in “Who’s Irish? ” the female parent eventually accepts the civilization around her at the terminal of the narrative when she moves in with Bess Shea. She encounters things of the new civilization and she doesn’t seem to mind them. such as watching blunders and the bird feeder. With these small alterations in civilization she will accommodate to the new home ground in which she is populating.
The similarity in “New York Day Women” is a small easier to understand because it happens throughout the full narrative. In the narrative “New York Day Women” the female parent walks down the street in Brooklyn while her girl is following her from buttocks. The female parent seems to hold a everyday she follows everyday. One illustration of the female parent encompassing a new civilization is when Suzette is draging behind. and notices that she stops at the seller on the side of the street and orders a hotdog. which is an American repast to most people.
Another illustration. of accepting a new civilization would be the statement of the cab drivers in forepart of Carnegie Hall. which is really common in New York to hold happen. So she sits and waits until the statement is over. The mother’s answer was. “In Haiti when you get hit by a auto. the proprietor of the auto gets out and boots you for acquiring blood on his bumper. ” These are illustrations of the similarities between the relationships in “New York Day Women. ” and “Who’s Irish? ”
There are besides many differences in the mother-daughter relationships of these short narratives. The first difference was how the two girls acted towards their mothers’ old traditions and imposts. The fact that Suzette was funny about the mother’s imposts and wanted to cognize more about it made the narrative “New York Day Women” a little more articulate. In the sense that I could state that Suzette knows her female parent really good. and will non halt being funny about her female parents traits. For illustration. in “New York Day Women” the Suzette follows her female parent around the streets of New York. She doesn’t want to be seen by her because she is seeking to see what she is does in the daylight. This wonder leads Suzette to larn how her female parent adapts to the metropolis life. On the other manus. in “Who’s Irish? ” Nattie does non truly care what her mother’s traditions are. She merely cares about the new manner a kid should be treated and the manner an American Acts of the Apostless.
This leads to confusion between Nattie and her female parent because both are seeking to coerce different imposts and civilizations Sophie. the girl of Nattie. Besides. in the terminal. Nattie is so distant from her female parent that she seldom goes over to Bess’ house to see her. The 2nd difference between these two narratives would hold to be the relationships between the two households. In “New York Day Women” the mother-daughter relationship is really near. Just the fact that the Suzette went to follow her female parent to larn her imposts is loving. but to hold about every sentence Begin with “My mother” is adequate grounds that there relationship is near adequate to do the household in “Who’s Irish? ” expression helter-skelter.
With this sort of relationship between them their mother-daughter relationship the love will ne’er stop. However. the mother-daughter relationship in “Who’s Irish? ” is atrocious. The female parent loves her girl. but she can’t show it to Nattie because she doesn’t want to allow travel of her traditions. This leads to the physical maltreatment of Sophie and exasperation from Nattie. which would head the relationship in a downhill form. The households portrayed in these two narratives depict really different mother-daughter relationships.
In decision. the relationships between female parents and their girl can change merely as the tides of the ocean. The mother-daughter relationship amongst different people can be the same. but besides really different. as seen in the short narratives. “Who’s Irish? ” and “New York Day Women. ” . However. in the terminal household relationships will predominate in good standing. and the love that was ever at that place will lift in the Black Marias of the households and all will be won in the battle for togertherness.